When Stories Break  

When Stories Break

Many writers will begin working on a novel and get “stuck.” They’ll lose interest in writing that book. Award-winning author Orson Scott Card spoke about this problem on our Apex call last week and pointed out that most of the time, it’s not too hard to get unstuck. 

There are a few reasons why writers develop “writer’s block.”

You started a story a while back that felt important and vital to you then, but you’ve matured, and it just doesn’t move you. 

When that happens, write something else. Your head and your heart need to be in agreement. Many prolific writers suggest that when you feel thrilled by a story, you should apply your butt to a chair and hammer it out in the heat of passion.

The truth is, two years from now you might not feel passionate about the piece, but it will be done, and the story can often be thrilling audiences long after you’ve grown tired of it.

Sometimes you’ll have an idea for a story that you’re not ready to write.  

You may feel you need to experience more. For example, I’m writing a story set in Fiji. I’ve been there twice on research trips but need to go for a longer visit—say three months, to do more research. It would be ideal to hammer out the first draft on location.

I’ve seen writers who want to write a story from the point of view of a “wiser” person, and the writers have a lot of pondering and maturing to do before they go to work. Tolkien said that he got his characters to the Mines of Moria, and for many years they all sat at the gate, waiting to enter. I’ve sometimes wondered if he really just needed to think about it, to try to write the book from a wiser perspective.

Usually when an author feels blocked, it is because something in the story is malformed.

When you study a story, it is much like peering into the innards of a fine watch. When you hold a Rolex in your hand, it feels weighty and precious. It runs with such precision, it seems simple.

But when you open the watch and peer in its innards, you discover a myriad of small moving parts: gears and coils and springs. And what in the world do the jewels in there do? 

When I’m asked to help fix a story, I ask myself questions like, “Is one of the characters busted? Is your hero really heroic? Is she growing in the right way? Is she properly invested in the welfare of others?”

Or your villain, is he frightening enough? Does he strike the reader as being convincing, or is he one dimensional?

Is a vital scene missing?  Or has the author thrown in pieces that don’t quite fit or even belong. (This last one is very often the case.)

When you discover you don’t want to write, it is normally because your subconscious is telling you something is broken.  

At that point, you need to reimagine the tale. First, go back a bit and figure out where you went wrong. One old writer used to advise going back to the past two or three writing sessions and just “throw out the garbage.” Get rid of it entirely. It’s easier to rewrite it than it is to figure out where you began drifting off course.

Warning: most writers hesitate to throw away bad work. They fear losing something precious.  But treat stale work the same way you treat spoiled food. You wouldn’t eat a moldy burrito, would you? Sure, you could scrape off the mold and down it, hoping it doesn’t kill you, but why bother? You should be just as eager to dispose of broken scenes as you are moldy food. 

Go back and find the vital healthy parts of your story, then move forward.

In most cases, these pieces of advice should get you back on track, but be aware that sometimes there are real physical reasons why people can’t write. These may include clinical depression (which can be caused by bacteria, viruses, or seasonal affective disorder), but can also be caused by brain fog, anxiety or stress. So look to your story first, but if you have chronic health problems, you might try talking to a doctor. The solution might be as simple as taking a copper supplement or reducing your gluten intake.

***Announcements***

Link to Robert Zangari’s Kickstarter which has already funded but is now working on meeting some cool stretch goals:  https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/lokpublishing/epic-fantasy-novel-the-prisoner-of-tardalim?ref=c1590g 

Our story bundle and warn that it ends tomorrow. “Get the fantasy fix you need, for a price you set!” https://storybundle.com/fantasy?fbclid=IwAR31U9uQzpNDE279KcxbQkGFI8e6gcaT2ioM780LI-73lQVC8FCJd2XLmnw

Last week we heard from Terry Brooks and Orson Scott Card.  It’s like a traveling conventions with bestselling authors, editors, publishers, agents, and artists. Throw in thousands of dollars in free writing workshop and live writing groups, and we’re trying to create the best value for writers on the web, at only $19.95 per month or $209 for an entire year.

Whether you want to break into the publishing field, level up to bestseller, or begin selling more books than you’ve ever imagined, in Apex you’ll find the writing classes, motivational tools, and support group you need.

Go to www.apex-writers.com to learn more.

Leave a Reply

Did you like this writing tip?
Click below to share with your friends

Related Posts
how to get a book published
David Farland

How to Get a Book Published 

Are you looking to publish a book? Let me tell you how to get it done.  Today, there are two paths to publishing: traditional publishing and self- (or independent) publishing.  

READ THIS POST
david farland jackie chan
David Farland

How to Build a Better Outline For Your Novel

You probably wouldn’t sink a million dollars into building a home without a blueprint. You certainly wouldn’t begin creating something as intricate as a cathedral without detailed plans. So why would you sink a year or two into composing a novel without plotting it?

READ THIS POST
how to write a short story
David Farland

How to Write a Short Story

As lead judge to the world’s largest competition for sci-fi and fantasy short fiction, David Farland can tell you exactly how to write a short story that’s a winner. The

READ THIS POST
how to write a book
David Farland

How to Write a Book

If you aren’t excited about a novel, chances are excellent that you’ll lack the energy to finish it. Your subconscious will rebel at the idea, and you’ll just go through the motions, wishing that you were working on another project. So you have to find story ideas that thrill you. You have to write from the heart.

READ THIS POST
How to write a book
David Farland

How to Write Your First Five Pages

How to Write Your First Five Pages:
1. From the very first sentence, I want to see that you’re not just a competent writer, but a skillful one.

I want to see that you have a way with words, so that I feel as if I’m in the hands of a professional storyteller. That means that I won’t feel confused, and I won’t get tripped up by typos or beginner’s mistakes. Indeed, I want to see that you’re talented right from the first sentence. Half of the editors and agents say that they look for a great voice right out the gate, whether it be the voice of the narrating character or of the author.

READ THIS POST
A colorful light bulb in front of interlocking red, yellow, and blue gears, symbolizing creativity and productivity working together.
Tammy Burke

Brainstorming for Stories: How to Turn Sparks into Worlds

Brainstorming is one of the most magical—and challenging—parts of being a writer. Ideas may arrive in a rush or drip in slowly, but either way, they form the first threads of story. The truth? Waiting for inspiration won’t always serve you. Instead, the key is to explore how to spark fresh ideas from familiar tropes, surprising “what ifs,” and creative collisions. Originality doesn’t mean inventing something brand new—it means putting your unique spin on timeless patterns so readers experience them as both familiar and exciting.

READ THIS POST
A figure in a bright red cloak walks across a black-and-white field toward a tree whose shadow stretches long across the ground. The word “Foreshadowing” appears in dark red letters to the right.
Tammy Burke

Foreshadowing in Writing:

Foreshadowing is the art of planting clues that make your story’s twists feel both surprising and inevitable. Learn the different types of foreshadowing, strategies for layering clues, and how to test your twist so it hits the perfect balance.

READ THIS POST
Stone statue of a robed woman, captured against a dramatic sunrise sky with soft orange and blue clouds, symbolizing inspiration and waiting.
Special Guest

Why Your Writing Muse Isn’t Your Friend

Too many writers wait for the writing muse to return, convinced that inspiration is the only way forward. But waiting keeps you stuck, staring at the page. The truth? Momentum is born not from longing, but from action. Start writing, and the muse may find you already at work.

READ THIS POST
No more posts to show

Wait, before you go… Be sure to grab a FREE copy of Dave's Proven Writer Tips for 100 Days!

Daily meditations Writer Tips for 100 days book image
Daily meditations Writer Tips for 100 days book image

Enter your name and email below to get it delivered straight to your inbox!

Brandon Sanderson
Brandon Sanderson#1 New York Times bestselling author of The Way of Kings and Mistborn
Read More
"I still use the writing techniques he discussed, and constantly reference him and his instruction when I teach creative writing myself. . . His explanations led me directly to getting an agent, and subsequently, my first book deal."